On Saki, Competitive Anime, and Kaiji
by Moonlily on Oct.22, 2009, under Anime
Just this past weekend, I finished the moe mahjong series Saki and if there was one thing that struck me about that show, it was how predictable it was. To illustrate that point, when a friend let me know that an individual tournament was about to begin and asked me to predict the winners, I rattled off the names of all three winners accurately. My reasoning at the time was that two of the characters were instrumental to the story while the third is a major fan-favorite and I suppose that the producer or manga artist felt the same way so to ensure the goal of a cohesive, friendship-bound story as well as attracting eyeballs, they are allowed to move on. If it were up to me, I’d have the trio of Hisa, scrub/noob-chan (mostly for sheer irony), and Stealth Momo advance, but I digress.
The ease in which I was able to guess the winners shows just how ridiculously predictable competitive anime tends to be. While most of the shows are fun to watch, the tension they produce is manufactured; you already know that when two teams or individuals clash, which will emerge victorious simply because if the other person won, there really wouldn’t be much of a story. After all, are we really supposed to be surprised when Azuma Kazuma and company were able to advance after every single bread matchup in Yakitate Japan? Or what about Takumi conquering most of his opponents with relative ease in Initial D? Armed with this bit of insight, the anime in question is effectively forced to squeeze as much drama and tension out of the matches to make them interesting. In other words, it’s an elaborate charade, one that Saki in particular delivers upon in an enjoyable fashion, but it’s a charade nonetheless.
As you can guess from the title, this is where my discussion on Kaiji comes in. Kaiji, like other competitive anime is also predictable; after all its longer title is Ultimate Survivor Kaiji and the overall point of the show cannot be made plainer than through that title. You know that Kaiji going to come out of the various contests in which he participates alive, but what makes this series gripping is that you don’t know how much of himself will be lost as a result.
Kaiji takes the road less traveled by putting an element of danger into its competitions. We’re not talking about the danger arising from, say, a showdown between two Bleach characters (this also falls under manufactured tension by the way). In Kaiji, the dangers are real; the situations in which the competitors are placed into are so over-the-top insane that one would be lucky to come out of it alive and in one piece, both physically and mentally. The amount of physical and emotional duress that the contests’ participants are subject to are monstrous and inhumane. Yet, it’s difficult to avert our gaze because deep inside us, there’s a sadistic curiosity to be had in watching misfortune. It’s the same reason why we are held spellbound by a burning train wreck.
Threats like the loss of life, of limb, or of sanity serve to make Kaiji a fascinating watch as the contestants lose their ability to empathize with others, viewing them as obstacles to their very own survival. Watching this degeneration is riveting because the ultimate outcome of each contest might be predictable, but what isn’t predictable is the physical and psychological toll that the contest exacts upon Kaiji. I recognize that not all competitive anime can operate on this level of tension and drama, but it would be nice to break from the formulaic competitive anime plot and have the competitors literally put their skin in the game. Or dress it up around character interactions/relationships a la Cross Game.






October 22nd, 2009 on 3:28 am
This is a tough one. I agree, in that predictability in competition stories is (duh) bad, & yet – my favourite competition anime stories are predicated on the success of their heroes and maintain very high interest throughout. Some part of me regularly forgets that Ippo always wins (except when he doesn’t!) or that Sora or Hikaru will no doubt prevail. Comparing Kaleidostar to Kaiji is weird, but Sora risks her integrity and dreams, and in that particular starry-eyed universe, it grips me & frightens me as much as does risking body parts does in Kaiji.
October 22nd, 2009 on 3:51 am
Eyeshield 21 threw an interesting curve in the drawings of the final tournament. There were three other teams you’re familiar with going into the tournament: the overall strongest team, the rival team, and the childhood friend’s team. The order ended up as follows:
Round 1: Strongest team
Round 2: Rival team
Round 3: A new team that beat the childhood friend’s team
It was quite surprising, especially to not see them square off against the rival team last.
I’ve heard brief, uninformative rumors about Kaiji’s fate in the upcoming season. Supposedly he screws up quite a bit. I don’t know if that means he’ll still win out in the end, but it certainly makes things more interesting to think there’s some small possibility he might not make it.
October 22nd, 2009 on 11:53 pm
@ojisan
The level of predictability isn’t a bad thing per se as long as one realizes it and isn’t fooled into thinking that the protagonists will lose. This puts more of an onus on making the drama palatable and in the examples you’ve cited, I think those work fine for their respective shows. I do have to watch Kaleido Star though and given this season’s slim offerings, I might break out the DVDs that have been sitting wrapped on the shelves.
@Baka-Raptor
That is an interesting decision though I do wonder whether not having a match against the friend’s team takes away from the drama or makes the matches have more emotional significance.
In any event, as we saw from the last last competition that Kaiji goes into, that was one major screwup. Hope the ones that you allude to will be as sobering since the outcome of the last challenge was probably one of the best parts of the anime series.
March 24th, 2010 on 11:53 pm
Thanks for the great episode
i love animee..
April 3rd, 2010 on 8:49 pm
Nice =) also great sites’ look =)